Hand-crafted gift baskets to celebrate life’s most special moments

Celebrate everything with a touch of fancy™

Discover our signature collection of handcrafted baskets, each designed to deliver an unforgettable moment of delight. See what's trending now, and shop all to find the perfect gift for any occasion.

All Things Indiana
$80.00

NOW ACCEPTING PRE-ORDERS

No… we don’t know, officially, why we are called Hoosiers, but it comes with a sense of pride and hospitality!

These baskets included some samples and fun facts about a few of the items Indiana is proudly known for:

•The Indianapolis Motor Speedway – For over 115* years, it has hosted the world’s largest one-day sporting event: The Indianapolis 500.  *The first race was run in 1911, but there were a few years where the race was not run due to WW1 and WW2.

•Abbott’s Candy – Founded in Hagerstown, IN. The state’s oldest candy shop, since 1890.

•Orville Redenbacher - born in Brazille, IN, in 1907 and the founder of the famous popcorn of the same name. Orville tested thousands of hybrid popcorn strains to create a superior, “fluffier” popcorn.

•Albanese Gummi Bears - Located in Merrillville, IN and said to produce “The world’s best gummi bears” for over 40 years.

•Triple XXX Root Beer – Produced since 1895. The last remaining “Thirst Station” is in West Lafayette, IN. The X used to be a grading system in the food & beverage industry.  X= Good.  XX= Better.  XXX= The Best!

•“Parks and Recreation” takes place in the fictional town of Pawnee, IN.

•The local universities are all top-notch and we can make sure your baskets represent your favorite(s)!

The suggestions for our Hoosier state are endless! Let’s chat!

One-of-a-kind Easter Gift
$70.00

Perfect for your favorite Easter host, or to ship to someone who cannot enjoy the holiday with you. Like many of my gift baskets, this is one of a kind. It carries simple, natural colors throughout, yet adds a little fancy with the beaded silver and pearl bunnies on the plush lumbar pillow. This also includes a lovely scented candle tin, resin bunny, a lavender lotion bar, and a sweet white, block cross.

Self-Care Gift Basket
$90.00

Includes a tin of mini heart shaped lotion bars w flower petals (see photo)*, organic lip sugar scrub, long lasting lip balm made with natural ingredients, Jojoba oil blend manicure oil, chocolate hearts, “Spa Day” lightly scented reed diffuser, a champagne flavored lollipop with freeze-dried strawberry bits and edible gold flakes, whipped body scrub made with premium-grade phthalate-free fragrance oils and essential oils, and adaptogen infused sparkling water. (Organic and Vegan. Lightly carbonated, free from additives, sweeteners and artificial flavors.)

*Heart shaped lotion bars may be replaced with a standard shaped lotion bar (of equal quality), depending upon the supplier and various holidays.

A row of gift baskets wrapped in clear cellophane with blue ribbons, sitting on a wooden counter inside a rustic wooden room.
Close-up of eucalyptus leaves in a basket.
Close-up of blue hydrangea flowers.

Gifting elevated

Have a specific person or moment in mind? We are happy to work with you to secure unique, one-of-a-kind items to create the perfect gift. Just reach out to work with us directly.

  • "I've sent holiday gift baskets to my clients for years. Last year I lost my basket creator to retirement, and she recommended Karen to fill in her void. The quality and craftsmanship of Karen's work is a match. I was super happy with the product and plan to use The Fancy Fish next year for my holiday gifting."

    — Dr. Jeff Klemens, DVM Owner/Operator Reliable Relief Services, LLC

  • “We have used Fancy Fish before it existed. Karen’s success is due to her details to what your needs are. But more importantly, it’s because she truly cares about her clients beyond business but as human beings and that makes all the difference.”

    — Barbara Zoderer, Builders Association of Greater Indianapolis

  • "I love supporting businesses where you can truly feel the heart behind them - and that’s exactly what Karen has created. Her gift baskets are thoughtful, beautifully styled, and filled with items you actually want to use and enjoy. It’s clear she puts care into every detail. I would confidently recommend her to anyone looking for a meaningful gift for a friend, family member, client, or special occasion."

    – Penny Siml, Carrington Homes

“I started Fancy Fish™ Custom Gift Baskets because I love spreading joy! Unique, personalized gift baskets seem to do just that! I search for and/or create unique products to build a gift that is sincerely special. And, I always add a touch of fancy.

— Karen Karr, Owner

A woman stands behind a table under a canopy at an outdoor event called Realtor Day, hosted by Fancy Fish, displaying various gift items and promotional materials.
Close-up of rippling ocean water with sunlight reflecting off the surface.
Woman standing at outdoor booth with a table covered in a white cloth displaying the logo and name of 'FISH'. The table has a gift basket wrapped in clear plastic with a blue bow, and various gift items and brochures. Green grass, trees, and houses are visible in the background.
A wicker basket filled with white and green flowers on a gray surface.