Our Story

A woman in a white shirt standing behind a table displaying gifts under a blue canopy. The table has a white cloth with the Fancy Fish logo and text 'CUSTOM GIFTS'. There is a sign on a cart that reads 'Welcome to Realtor Day Hosted by: Fancy Fish'. Various gift baskets wrapped in cellophane and other items are on the table and cart. A grassy lawn and house are in the background.

Why Fancy Fish?

I was often called “Fish” growing up because my maiden name is Fisher. I also learned at a young age that life can change in an instant, and every day is a gift!  So I find it important to celebrate everything! Celebration creates memories and slows the world from spinning one day right into the next. Stop. Take a breath. And, enjoy everything around you.

I started Fancy Fish™ Custom Gift Baskets because I love spreading joy! Unique, personalized gift baskets seem to do just that! I search for and/or create unique products to build a gift that is sincerely special. And, I always add a touch of fancy.

Let me create a memorable, unique gift from you!

– Karen Karr, Owner

Intentional Curation

We believe that great gifts are built with purpose.

Memorable Joy

We strive to create moments that spark genuine delight for both you and your recipient.

Thoughtful Integrity

We operate with transparency, sourcing high-quality gifting items from trustworthy and responsible vendors and craftspeople.

Our values

Flat lay of small gift boxes decorated with purple lilac flowers, surrounded by sprigs of lilac flowers, scissors, a spool of twine, and a soft pink fabric on a white wooden surface.

  • "I've sent holiday gift baskets to my clients for years. Last year I lost my basket creator to retirement, and she recommended Karen to fill in her void. The quality and craftsmanship of Karen's work is a match. I was super happy with the product and plan to use Fancy Fish Custom Gifts next year for my holiday gifting."

    — Dr. Jeff Klemens, DVM,Owner/Operator Reliable Relief Services, LLC

  • “We have used Fancy Fish before it existed. Karen’s success is due to her details to what your needs are. But more importantly, it’s because she truly cares about her clients beyond business but as human beings and that makes all the difference. ”

    — Barbara Zoderer, Builders Association of Greater Indianapolis

  • “I love supporting businesses where you can truly feel the heart behind them — and that’s exactly what Karen has created. Her gift baskets are thoughtful, beautifully styled, and filled with items you actually want to use and enjoy. It’s clear she puts care into every detail. I would confidently recommend her to anyone looking for a meaningful gift for a friend, family member, client, or special occasion.”

    — Penny Siml, Carrington Homes

  • “I have been very pleased with the baskets from Fancy Fish! The first basket was for my niece’s graduation. Karen took the time to research the activities that my niece is involved in at her school and made the basket very personalized. My niece loved it! Karen also built a beautiful birthday basket for my sister-in-law. It was full of my SIL’s favorite things and colors! At Thanksgiving, Karen created a really fun Thanksgiving basket full of candy that our family used for a door prize. It was a huge hit! All have been put together with love and care for the intended recipient. I’ll definitely be using Fancy Fish Custom Gifts again!”

    — R. Perkins